Can a Landlord Keep Your Security Deposit for Normal Wear and Tear?
Published November 9, 2026 · 5 min read
No. In every state, a security deposit can only be charged for damage beyond normal wear and tear — the gradual decline that happens just from living in a home. Faded paint, lightly worn carpet, small nail holes: that's the cost of being a landlord, priced into rent, and it cannot come out of your deposit.
The fight is over where the line sits. Here's how to see it clearly — and how to make sure you're standing on the right side of it.
Wear and tear vs damage: the working lists
Normal wear and tear (not deductible in any state):
- Paint fading, minor scuffs, and small nail holes from hanging pictures
- Carpet worn in traffic paths (not stained, burned or torn)
- Faded curtains or blinds, loose door handles, worn faucet washers
- Minor scratches on hardwood from everyday use
- Appliance wear consistent with its age
Damage (legitimately deductible)
One more limit landlords often skip: depreciation. If you damage a carpet that was already eight years into a ten-year life, you owe the remaining value — about 20% of replacement cost — not a brand-new carpet. Courts apply this routinely; deduction lists that ignore it are challengeable.
- Stains, burns, tears or pet damage to carpet and flooring
- Large holes in walls, broken windows, damaged doors
- Missing fixtures, broken appliances from misuse
- Smoke or odor remediation after a no-smoking lease was breached
- Cleaning needed beyond ordinary living — the unit left dirty is chargeable in most states
- Unpaid rent and charges you agreed to in the lease
How deductions must be documented
Nearly every state requires an itemized statement within the return deadline: each deduction named, with its cost. "Damages: $400" as a single line satisfies almost no statute. In several states a missing or late itemization voids the deductions entirely, however real the damage was.
The deadlines each state sets are in our guide to deposit return deadlines by state.
If your deposit was docked for wear and tear
- Ask in writing for the itemized statement and invoices if you didn't get them
- Compare each line against your move-in and move-out photos
- Reply line by line: name the items that are ordinary wear, and cite your state's deposit statute
- If the excess isn't returned, small claims court is built for exactly this — and several states add penalties for bad-faith withholding
Start by confirming the deposit itself was within your state's legal cap: security deposit calculator.